|
|
|
|
|||||
|
|||||||
|
THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PERFORMANCE | ||||||
| By Judith E. Brulo | |||||||
|
AGSM. PGCE (OU).MICHT. VTCT, SNHS (Indian Head Massage)., SNHS (Ad. Ref.). |
|||||||
|
WE WILL CONSIDER TWO ASPECTS OF THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PERFORMANCE: 1. Personality Profile: the Musician and Links with Sport. 2. Stress, Arousal and Anxiety in Performance: with specific reference to solo performance. |
|||||||
|
Imagine the formation of a spider's web. Isn't this like the numerous interconnecting threads in the preparation for a performance? To address each thread in detail would be far beyond the scope of this article. It is my intention, therefore, to concentrate on two of these threads. The first of these will be Personality Profile: the Musician and Links with Sport and second Stress Arousal and Anxiety in Performance: with specific reference to solo performance. (Perhaps the spider doesn't have these problems)! The personality and sport topics will be addressed first and separately. Then, I shall address the preparation of the solo performance and stress management. On this second topic, rather than proposing entirely my thoughts on preparation for performance and performance-stress, it seemed a more interesting and sensible notion to present a broader knowledge. Therefore, by means of interviews, I have gathered information from the experience of other musicians. |
|||||||
|
The interviewees are solo professional performers and teachers. They were chosen because they present variety and excellence in their training and extensive experience in performing and teaching. Amongst these are performers of instrumental specialisms outside the string family. I have included these deliberately so that we can learn the psychological performing techniques of as many musicians as possible. |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
|
Personality Profile: the Musician and Links with Sport |
|||||||
|
The main focus of this section concerns definitions of personality whilst paying separate attention to musicians and solo artistes. Information will be drawn from current literature on the psychology of music performance and related topics. (These are referenced at the end of the article). The importance of understanding personality profile is expressed succinctly by Anthony Kemp, a writer many of you may know as the author of the fascinating book "The Musical Temperament" (1996). He writes; "Such a profile might be viewed as a window into the musician's deeper psychology and as an indicator of the demands that the development of these musical skills constantly makes upon the individual. By addressing these kinds of questions we are able to develop a broader understanding about the nature of musicianship and the ways in which musical skill interrelates with temperament, thus providing a more comprehensive view of what musicians do and why. In other words, it is not only what people are able to do that determines their work but also what kind of people they are." (Kemp 1996. Preface). |
|||||||
|
In his chapter 'Individual differences in musical behaviour,' he writes. "Clearly musicians engage in highly cognitive processes and execute exceedingly complex skills..............The development of these, in many respects, is dependent upon the existence or acquisition of unusual combinations of personality factors." (Kemp. 1997. In Hargreaves and North 1997. P. 25). |
|||||||
|
We will look at the manner in which personality factors interact with
performance particularly drawing from the discipline of sport. Here the
focus will be on stress, arousal and anxiety, in a performing situation. |
|||||||
|
Unfortunately, not everyone shares this view. In his book Performing Music, Shared Concerns, Jonathan Dunsby (1997) describes a negative comparison between sport and music. It is evident that Dunsby's focus is on the actual performance of music but it is regrettable that he did not also take into consideration the intricate process through which a performance is achieved. We can conceivably acknowledge the fact that the social, emotional and expressive elements between the two disciplines are different but there is clearly more to sport than the final result of the race. |
|||||||
|
If we begin with the premise that the personality of the musician largely dictates how she/he will tackle this performance task, then it follows that we need to know the answer to this question. What is personality? |
|||||||
|
Personality structure exists on three fundamental levels. Picture a veneered piece of wood with three layers. The outside and most visible layer is the 'role-related behaviour'. Those who care to delve a little deeper see the next layer, 'typical responses,' and the innermost layer; the layer that shows what is really there is called the 'psychological core.' My son is studying sports' science at University and in his reading list I came across a book by Weinberg and Gould, "Foundations of Sport and Exercise Psychology." In the chapter "Personality and Sport" we read: "Getting to know the real person (psychological core) and typical modes of response produces insight into motivation, actions, and behaviour." (Weinberg and Gould 1995. P.38). |
|||||||
|
The psychological core is the most difficult layer to penetrate and it is the most stable part of the personality, it stays more or less constant over time. There are three major approaches to personality; trait, situational (sometimes called state) and interactional (or social). |
|||||||
|
Trait Approach.
This approach takes the view that the basic units of personality are
relatively stable. The circumstances or situation a person finds him/herself
in, will have little effect on his/her basic behavioural patterns. The most
well known proponents of this theory, active in the 1960's and 1970's, were
Gordon Allport, Raymond Cattell and Hans Eysenck. Eysenck took the view
that traits were relative, the most important traits "ranging on continuums
from introversion to extroversion and from stability to emotionality." |
|||||||
|
Situation Approach. In contrast, this approach takes into account the situation or environment in which an individual finds him/herself. It proposes that behaviour is significantly determined by environment. The developmental psychologist Albert Bandura, developed the Social Learning Theory (1977). This is when behaviour is learned by modeling and social reinforcement. As an example; imagine a person who has the personality trait of shyness. This person sees someone in a dangerous situation and acts aggressively in order to protect them. On this occasion the situation has been the determining influence over the normal personality trait. The situation approach, like the trait approach, cannot stand on its own as a predictor of behaviour because both trait and state (situation) are interactional. |
|||||||
|
Interactional Approach. This is an approach, which considers trait and situation as co-determinants of behaviour. The studies of Bowers (1973) revealed that ''the interaction between persons and situations could explain twice as much behaviour as traits or situations alone.'' (Weinberg and Gould 1995. P40). |
|||||||
|
My earlier
proposition, that sports' science studies offers significant help to the
musician-performer, can be supported by the following example found in
Weinberg and Gould (Ibid.). The example is taken from the studies of Fisher
and Zwart (1982) on the effect of anxiety on athletes in different
basketball situations: |
|||||||
|
Given these situations, the athletes were asked to report to what degree
they would react in these ways (worded as in the study):
a. Get an uneasy feeling.
b. React overemotionally.
c. Want to avoid the situation |
|||||||
|
The individual's reactions are determined by their personality. One person
who is by nature, anxious, might react by getting that "choking" feeling,
whereas a more relaxed 'laid back' person might enjoy the challenge. The
musical parallels to these situations are not difficult to imagine.
Inventories of trait and state measurements can be found in the work of many
psychologists and the following list might be of interest to those who wish
to delve further |
|||||||
|
Situation Specific Measures.
This approach considers the personality of the individual and the specific
situation (interactional approach). Let us turn our attention to studies in
the field of music. We read in "Psychology for Performing Artists:
Butterflies and Bouquets" by Glenn D. Wilson (1994) that Salmon et al.
(1989) carried out situation specific tests to determine the timing of
anxiety in music students prior to and during performance. Their findings
''suggest that experienced performers learn to let their arousal peak |
|||||||
|
The effects of these anxiety peaks were also measured and it was found that the anxiety of the inexperienced performer affected the performance as a negative fear reaction but the experienced performer was able to channel the anxiety into focused attention. In sport, a coach who has gathered together the personality profile of a player will then devise means of building up his/her strengths and eliminating the weaknesses. There is insufficient evidence to suggest that musicians have specific equivalent help available, except through the advice and experience of the instrumental teacher. This advice may not always be based on solid foundations. |
|||||||
|
Previously alluded to was Anthony Kemp's view, that the personality of the musician is essentially introspective, "..... musicians are generally characterized by a distinct tendency to be introverted. Bearing in mind the nature of their working environment, this is not a difficult notion to develop, although it may have several different facets" (Kemp. 1996. P.40.). |
|||||||
|
Kemp then goes on to discuss findings that suggest that "the
levels of introversion appear to be related to different levels of
performing success." (P.40). He further suggests that brass players and
singers show more extroversion than other musicians. And his conclusion is
this. "The musician can be perceived as a bold introvert who possesses the
capacity to be comfortable in solitude during long periods of practice but |
|||||||
|
It is pertinent to give this final paragraph to the reader. "The view developed here is that this reflects musicians' very special form of auditory style, which allows them to create an internal and imaginative world of sound, rich in symbolism and indispensable for creative activity in music. It also suggests that this aspect of musicians' temperament also links with motor imagery and refined levels of motor control, and it is speculated that this may have connections with arousal levels. Arousal theory suggests that introverts are superior at tasks that are perceived as boring and monotonous by the more extraverted. On the other hand they can suffer from over stimulation, and their performances can deteriorate more rapidly than those of extraverts under higher stress conditions." (P.50. Ibid.). |
|||||||
|
Now, a word about soloists. |
|||||||
|
Soloists. Although we have an idea of the personality profiles of musicians who work in orchestral situations, we have less idea about solo artists. Kemp gives us an indication about pianists, organists and singers. He suggests that they are "distinctly extraverted" (Kemp 1996. P.181. Kemp's Italics) and that they are distinguished from other musicians because of their "higher levels of conscientiousness and self-sentiment coupled with their distinct conservatism and lack of anxiety." (P.181. Ibid.). |
|||||||
|
Singers, apparently show higher levels of extraversion, greater sensitivity and independence. Therefore, Kemp suggests, they are more composed and 'together.' The violinmaker and restorer, Adam Whone includes the following amusing article in his latest newsletter. "Singers are judged by different standards. It is an old saw that people are either gifted with musicianship or with a good voice; thus a singer exhibiting the slightest trace of artistic sensibility is welcomed by an orchestra however inadequate the voice may be." (Whone. 2000). |
|||||||
|
He gives a general description of instrumental soloists as "a musician who, by virtue of an over-developed technique and an excess of individuality, is unsuited to playing in orchestras." (Ibid). |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
| The Interviewees and how they manage the stress of performance | |||||||
|
The performer-interviewees are soloists and orchestral musicians in various capacities. They are: Christopher Hirons. Violinist. Professor of Baroque Violin at the Royal College of Music. Caroline Bosanquet. Cellist, pianist, composer, lecturer. Damien Royannais. Saxophonist, string bassist, Nicholas Toller. Pianist, lecturer, composer. Elizabeth Wood. Singer, teacher. Michel Sedgwick. Trumpeter, teacher. Judith Brulo. Violist, teacher. Their mission - that of learning a piece for solo, chamber orchestra and conductor - was presented to them. Those questions relating to physical preparation and stress are embedded in the following text. There were seven interviews, five of which were conducted personally. In these five, the line of questioning was adapted to accommodate the flow of conversation but essentially each person's questioning covered the same material. The interview questions presented to Elizabeth Wood and Nicholas Toller, were conducted by e-mail. |
|||||||
|
CHRISTOPHER HIRONS: Violinist. |
|||||||
|
CAROLINE BOSANQUET: 'Cellist. |
|||||||
|
DAMIEN ROYANNAIS: Saxophone. |
|||||||
|
NICHOLAS TOLLER: Pianist. |
|||||||
|
ELIZABETH WOOD: Singer. |
|||||||
|
MICHEL SEGWICK: Trumpeter. |
|||||||
|
JUDITH BRULO: Violist & Teacher. |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
| Suggestions for the Remedy of Performance Stress | |||||||
|
The performer who is aware of his/her personality type will be better equipped to find a remedy or a mixture of remedies for performance stress, thus enabling him/her to have the freedom to perform comfortably and creatively. Methods of preparation for performance stress are available for performers who operate in a variety of skills, even pistol shooting - as the mother of one of my students informed me, (I must remember to be nice to her daughter). These methods are outlined below. |
|||||||
|
Drugs. Alcohol, valium and marijuana, which are 'anxiolytic' drugs, can give the performer, himself, the feeling of wellbeing but the audience may come away with a different view. As time goes on, the need for greater dose increases and dependency results. The end result is neither helpful for ones health or ones performance. The Beta-Blocker, Propranolol, has proved to be effective in controlling the adrenal based effects such as butterflies, bow tremor, sweating etc. Sometimes it can produce a dry mouth, sleep disturbance, nausea, depression. However, the performances of musicians can be enhanced. Psychological methods are the best recourse. Amongst them are: |
|||||||
|
Progressive Muscular Relaxation. This is a technique, which was devised by Jacobson in 1929. It is a method whereby the client proceeds through the body, asking the various muscle groups to relax. Usually it begins at the extremities of the body. The client is asked to breathe deeply, saying 'relax' as he/she breathes out. |
|||||||
|
Biofeedback. This is a way of monitoring mental relaxation. Seeing the progress one is making, encourage positive responses. There are computer programmes available. RelaxPlus, devised by Geake (1992), is one such programme. |
|||||||
|
Meditation. This has its origins in the East and was originally connected to Yoga. The client has to adopt a certain sitting position and repeat a word, called a mantra. This has the effect of slowing down the vital functions of the body; heart rate, blood pressure, respiration and metabolism. Autogenic Training |
|||||||
|
This also functions by means of the repetition of certain phrases. These are more direct than the mantra and aimed to produce specific body response. The client uses phrases such as ''my arms are feeling heavy'' etc. The aim is that of passive concentration and is permissive rather than compulsive Hypnotic Suggestion. |
|||||||
|
This form of suggestion therapy uses deep hypnotic trance, in which the
therapist suggests to the client, feelings of heaviness of limbs and
eyelids. Deep slow breathing, sleepiness and attention to the voice of the |
|||||||
|
Aerobic Exercise. Aerobic exercise is good for you! Encouraging a moderately increased heart rate for about half an hour can be of positive benefit to conquering depression and anxiety. The brain produces opiates - endorphins, which help to reduce pain and give a feeling of well-being. Holmes and McGilley (1987) suggest that exercise encourages resistance to psychological stress. We must include here, the benefits of sleep. This is equally important in helping to cope with stress. It is very important to have some early nights prior to a performance. Going to bed in the afternoon, before the evening performance is very beneficial. Some of the interviewees do this, as I do too. |
|||||||
|
Alexander Technique. Alexander technique aims to restore the balance of the whole body, thus enabling the muscle groups to function at their most efficient capacity. Although this is not a relaxation technique, the feeling of control and well-being it encourages, gives the performer greater and efficiency and therefore confidence, in performance. It is very tempting to work the muscles hard in our effort to perform well. However, we have all experienced the phenomenon whereby not trying so hard produces better results. This study, from the realm of sport, is an example, which supports the Alexander Principle. |
|||||||
|
''In a study conducted with 400-meter runners, the runners were first asked
to run all out (i.e., give 110%). A few days later, the same runners were
asked to run at 95% of their capacity. Interestingly enough, the runners
ran faster at 95% than at 110%. Why this happens involves the effect that
muscle tension can have on skilled performance. Specifically, when running
at 110% runners were using all their energies and muscular capacities.
However, running - like most other sport activities - is performed most
effectively when some muscles are contracting while others are relaxing.
Thus, by using all of their muscles, agonists and antagonists, the runners
were using muscles that prevented them from running as fast as they could. |
|||||||
|
Cognitive Orientation. A study by Wolverton and Salmon (1991) suggests that in any situation, we have a limited amount of attention allocation. In the musical performance situation this could mean three possibilities. The self. How do I look? Is my playing up to my standard? The audience. What are their reactions? Do they look as if they are enjoying it? The music. Concentration on technical passages, interpretation. "Wolverton and Salmon found that absorption in the artistic work itself was associated with the lowest levels of anxiety. Almost certainly this would also go along with optimal performance.'' (Wilson 1994. P.199). |
|||||||
|
Cognitive therapy, therefore, would encourage the client to focus on the musical interpretation, rather that the self or the audience. Recall the interviewees in the study. All reported the importance of concentration on the musical interpretation. ''The music takes you through.'' (Christopher Hirons) |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
|
Stress Inoculation. This is a system, which does not deny feelings of anxiety or worry. Instead it channels and makes constructive use of these feelings. They are "'reframed' as less threatening, even desirable, reactions.'' (Wilson 1994. P.200). |
|||||||
|
If a performer catastrophises, the result may be that he/she avoids anything to do with the performance, even to the extent of avoiding practicing. Stress inoculation helps the performer to acknowledge that this is a positive way of highlighting an area of preparation, which needs to be attended to. The signs of increased heart beat, sweating, shallow breathing are reshaped and seen as normal and inconspicuous to the onlooker and of benefit to the excitement of the performance. This gradual exposure, combined with relaxation can be used to help the performer see the symptoms of stress as less threatening. |
|||||||
|
Self - Talk: 'Psyche yourself up.' This is good therapy! So often it is easy to remember the destructive comments that were made in the past. The harsh word that stays with us throughout our lives and comes to haunt us when we are under scrutiny. It is often the case that, in performance we have inner conversations with the critical parent or professor. I remember talking this problem through with a counseller. She asked me whether any of these damaging comments were justified, in the light of all the many other positive and encouraging comments that had come from people, for whom others and I had respect. |
|||||||
|
Goal Imaging. Some performers are more disposed towards visual imagery rather than self-talk. I remember reading an inspiring book about Jacqueline DuPre, and subsequently reflecting on her 'oneness' with the 'cello. There almost seemed to be an unbreakable link between her soul and her instrument. I finished the book a few hours before I was due to do a recital. I was able to implant that image in my mind and this helped me to think beyond myself, beyond the instrument, through to the music. This form of imagery can be used in hypnosis too. |
|||||||
|
Mental rehearsal is also valuable. It is frequently used in sport where the athlete pictures the moves he/she will make. I have found this extremely valuable too. Flying from Cyprus to Thessaloniki to do a Concerto, I was unable to have time to practice individually because of the schedule. During the flight, with the music in front of me, I visualised playing each note and each shift. (Some notes were out of tune)! The result was that I felt very comfortable and secure in the performance. Self-talk and goal imaging have, in common, optimism. "Those who envisage success, whether it be in sport, business, or on stage are more likely to perform at their best. The trick is to 'picture it perfect.' '' (Wilson 1994. P.201). |
|||||||
|
Self -Handicapping. Setting up excuses for failure, deliberately sabotaging the performance, for example, having too much to drink the night before. The performer can then say that they would have done better if it hadn't have been for this or that. The need for excuses can snowball and this is where the danger lies. In rehearsals it is common to hear a player saying that they have never seen the music before. This negative approach often leads to self-fulfilling prophecy. The antidote is to recognise it when it occurs and then replace it with positive strategies. |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
|
Summary of Instrumentalists' Contributions and Conclusion |
|||||||
|
The performers' stress management techniques have been developed and moulded through experience and they are tailored to the individual's personality. Just taking a selection of examples from the interviews; Elizabeth (singer) presents as a calm personality with considerable interpersonal skills. She is a very experienced performer and teacher. Before a performance, she uses 'self-talk' to convince herself that her performance is going to be successful and has learned to regulate the performance arousal level for optimum effect. This arousal regulation is true for the performers interviewed for this study and appears present in most experienced performers, thus supporting the view of G. Wilson (1994). For physical preparation, musicians who (by the nature of their instrument) rely on the breath, develop a regime of breathing exercises. In Michel's case (trumpeter) his preparation also includes aerobic sporting activities. |
|||||||
|
This exercise is part of his routine for Michel's normal practice schedule, but particularly important prior to performance. The other instrumentalists often do arm movements - the equivalent of breathing. So in a sense, some things are parallel. For example, amongst other strategies, Caroline (cellist) has a very well worked out preparation regime of arm exercises adapted from the Alexander Principle. Christopher Hirons (violinist) is an eminent and well-respected soloist and orchestral leader. He is extrovert, ebullient and warm-hearted. He is happiest in a leadership capacity. Although it appears that Chris requires very little physical and mental preparation, on the day of the performance he likes to rest and take things quietly. |
|||||||
|
His violinistic preparation is careful and thorough - although he's not really a solitary person. His talent and experience enables him to find efficient and creative ways of working. He is a very relaxed person and finds violin playing a very natural experience. Damien, the youngest of the interviewees (saxophonist) appears to match Anthony Kemp's view of the bold introvert. He enjoys practising for extended periods and is not happy when his practice routine is thwarted. In performance he projects an extrovert image. He enjoys company but it has to be of the right sort, just before he performs. |
|||||||
|
In this article I have attempted to show first, the importance of the correlation of psychology studies in sports' performance, to music performance. Second, to show the necessity of performers to be aware of their personality type in order that they might find benefit in developing a system for managing the physical demands of performance and performance related stress. These are just two of the many threads in the complicated web of performance. |
|||||||
|
But there is a third point to make. When we are teaching our students there is often the prospect of a performance lurking around the corner. Perhaps we could endeavour to be more aware of the personality types in our students and thus help them to find a formula to deal with their individual performance-preparation needs. |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
|
References
Allport, G.W. (ed.) (1960). Personality and social encounter. Boston: |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||
| There Are More Articles In Our Reading Room | |||||||
| If you wish to publish this article on your own website please contact webmaster@naturalhealthcourses.com | |||||||
|
If you enjoy helping others and would like to train for a secure future as a Complementary Therapist just follow the links below. |
|||||||
|
Website designed by Oak
Tree Web-builders |
|||||||
|
|
|||||||